6 Tips to Win Returning Visitors

To win returning visitors is one of those things that if you’re not intentional and don’t have a system, it won’t happen.

Visitors to Return

To win returning visitors is one of those things that if you’re not intentional and don’t have a system, it won’t happen. But if you want to see your church grow, then it’s vital to win returning visitors. Imagine if just half the visitors who attended a church service ended up coming back again and again, eventually becoming members. Your church would grow!

The great thing about being intentional about visitor assimilation is that they are already there. They have already encountered the culture of your church and have a taste of what it’s like to hear you preach a sermon. Their encounter could be good, bad or OK, but if you get this piece right, it could make all the difference.

6 Parts to Win Returning Visitors

1. Information Card

In order to win returning visitors you’ll need to get their contact information. You need an information card or connection card or whatever you want to call it. For us, our connection card is on every chair and is encouraged to be filled out by everyone as it’s our way for people to get signed up for events, submit prayer requests and more.

If you want to win returning visitors, you need to get their contact information.

2. Gift and Info Bag

Go all out with this! It will be the incentive for them to fill out their information card and turn it in. Blow them away with the value they receive from this bag.

We decided to include a $5 Panera Gift Card, a customized coffee mug with our colors and logo, an information folder explaining who we are and a business card.

3. Dedicated Visitor Table

When you do the next step (#4) you’ll need a place to tell them to go after service. This is that place. You’ll want to recruit a team of people to be at this table on a rotation so that you have coverage every week. Their job is to make sure that visitors fill out at least their name and email, engage with them as much as they are open to, and answer any questions they may have.

We call this our “Get Connected Table.” Whatever you decide to call it, be sure to get appropriate signage so that visitors know where to go without question.

4. Start With Them in Mind

From signage to cleanliness, keep the visitor in mind. Then, once your service starts, start with them in mind. Take some time at the beginning of the service to acknowledge their presence. Welcome them, invite them to fill out the information card and encourage them to take it to the table (#3) where they’ll receive a free gift bag.

5. Email Follow Up

Email may be a somewhat old technology, but it’s still extremely effective. We use MailChimp for this part. To do this, you’ll need to pay, at a minimum, $10 a month, but it’s completely worth it.

Every Monday, you’ll want to take the new information cards and plug in the information to your email list that is set up for email automation.

Over the course of a month we send out five different emails to visitors. I took the emails that Bobby Williams shared with the UnSeminary audience when he was featured on the UnSeminary Podcast and then modified them to meet our needs.

Check out the podcast episode here and get the emails here.

6. Visitor Video

In the first email that is sent to visitors they are invited to watch a short welcome video from our lead pastor, Kenny White (have you read his post on finding your preaching voice?).

Watch the visitor video.

Don’t overthink this video. Simply talk with the viewer (a visitor) as if they were right in front of you. Tell them you were glad they were there and invite them to come back.

Want More on How to Win Returning Visitors?

If this article on how to win returning visitors was helpful to you, subscribe to the blog. As a way of saying thank you, we’ll include four free resources: Sermon Evaluation Worksheet, 56 Weeks of Preaching TopicsSermon Series Planning Evernote Template and the Weekly Productivity Evernote Template. All this for free when you subscribe.

Brandon Kelley
Brandon Kelley is the co-founder of Rookie Preacher. He serves as the Outreach & Communications Pastor at a fast growing church plant in Williamsburg, Ohio, called The Crossing. Among the many things he does at The Crossing, serving on the teaching team is one of them. He also writes at BrandonKelley.org. You can follow him @BrandonKelley_. Watch his sermons here.